As much as I miss Quiznos, the only location left in NJ is temporarily closed. Pick the best hoagie for your health with our ultimate ranking. We also had the Italian dressing on the sub, per an employee's recommendation. And the sub! I ordered the six-inch Classic Italian sub with ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, oil, vinegar and oregano. So, depending on what you like or want, it was possible to spend six dollars at both places. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. There is not a lot of meat on this small sandwich, and it's incredibly dry. Wendy's was best by a slice. Sometime years ago, I visited my grandfather in North Carolina, and we went over to his friends house for dinner. They do have some items made with healthy-sounding ingredients, such as 99 percent lean turkey breastbut that doesn't mean their entire menu is free of high-calorie, -sodium, and -fat subs. The bun is literally loaded with ingredients, and as you can see, excellent distribution throughout. Gonzo: To me it tastes the most homemade out of any of the chains. Why are we so excited? Far higher quality than Subway, but also a few dollars more expensive. I loved all the spices, and the lettuce, tomato and onions, and you can add peppers if you want. Every location differs in quality as well. The tub is a salad, for those who have never been in. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time. While they seemed to skimp a bit on the meats and cheese, it tasted pretty fresh. JImmy Johns is much better. That's what I wanted to find out. That simple switch may tack on 30 calories, but it's surprisingly worth it for saving about 500 milligrams of sodium while adding 12 grams of proteinwhich is far too much protein for one meal, so definitely split it in half. Publix is the best of course, glad that's acknowledged. It has slightly less of everything, from calories to fat and sodium, and just a touch more protein. The fact that this cheesesteak exceeds 3,000 milligrams of sodium is just outright inexcusable. And when I got to the end, the sandwich had become a wet mess, sopping with an Italian dressing and a mayo-mustard goop. I love how thin and stringy the lettuce was. And eat local, at one of our many fabulous Michigan's Best establishments if you can. Oil and vinegar was used sparingly and gave the sub an extra kick. Jersey Mike's Subs Prices - Fast Food. While Jersey Mike's put up a good fight, Jimmy John's won me over with its speedy, friendly service and all-around delicious food. Both sub shops had the usual culprits: turkey, ham, meatball, Italian, tuna, and cheese steak. But at $7.50 for the regular eight-inch sandwich and $4 for the smaller Little John version, you cant really beat it. These new workers over the past few months have diminished the quality of food significantly. The beauty of Potbelly is the distribution of the sandwich ingredients from meats to vegetables. Costing $7.49 for a small, it may be a little over the top but the quality of the ingredients makes it worth the price. The Original Italian: Bread: 5.4 Fillings: 6.9 Toppings: 7.1 Value: 4.7 Overall: 6.0, Jersey Mikes Original Italian sub, left, and Jimmy Johns Vito sub. Weekend Buzz: Weekly, Events and Entertainment, Side dish: Weekly, Dining News and Reviews, ShoreCast: Weekly, Best of the New Jersey Shore, Specials: Occasional, Exclusive Contests, Deals and Offers, Occasional, Exclusive Contests, Deals and Offers, Rachel Zeglers Jersey Upbringing Prepared Her for Stardom, Middle Eastern Grill to Offer Free Items in Paramus; Other Dining News, Philly-Raised Chef Embraces South Jersey: It Has Such a Good Feeling, Englewood Mural Honors Black Womens Voices, Mahwah Farm Gives Those With Special Needs a Chance to Horse Around, Amid Global Shortages, NJ Breweries Look to Source More Locally, Five Star Real Estate Agents in New Jersey, Five Star Mortgage Professionals in New Jersey, Five Star Home/Auto Insurance Professionals in New Jersey. The one great thing about choosing a sub over a fast food burger is that it is usually a much healthier choice. You get meat in every bite, but not too thick a layer like in the Subway and Jersey Mikes subs which stack all the meat on one half of the bread. Every time I walk into a Firehouse Subs, I smell like one for the entire day. But costing $7.50 for a six-inch sub, this was a very solid sandwich, but a little overpriced. Not even Publix can top a Firehouse Italian! Both are good, but I prefer Jersey Mike's over Jimmy John's. The flavor was decent, and you get some of each ingredient in every bite because of how it's layered. I know everyones got their favorite order, but for the sake of this debate, I stuck with the Italian hoagie. And at Jersey Mikes, a number seven is a turkey and provolone, with the ability to add anything you would like. Blimpie Best: Bread: 6.0 Fillings: 5.9 Toppings: 6.0 Value: 5.4 Overall: 5.8, (from the 235 Prospect Avenue, West Orange location). Jersey Mike's makes a decent sub like you would expect from a deli in NJ. You can have your sub hot, or cold, but either way the par baked bread takes at least one trip through a conveyor belt oven. Full disclosure: I used to work at a Jimmy Johns in Illinois, so Ive witnessed its rise to success and eventual expansion to my home state. I tried Primos once when I was in Philadelphia and remember being impressed, especially with its crusty sesame seeded bread. Convenience is key, people. This sandwich is not the kind of club you want to belong to. Remember, the regular size subs are meant to be split in two, so that means you'd receive 20 grams of protein per serving. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Firehouse Subs also has a top-secret recipe for bread which is part of why their sandwiches always taste so fresh and delicious. Now I'm liking this "Fully Involved", it sounds somewhat kinky, but really just means you get mayo, deli mustard, lettuce, tomato, onion, and a kosher dill pickle on the side. Way, way, way better. Since every day is sub day if you want it to be, I decided to have three sub days: one at Subway, one at Jimmy John's, and one at Jersey Mike's. Honestly i find Jersey Mikes flavor of their meat to be superior. Instead, go for the mini and you'll save yourself 1,000 milligrams of bloat-inducing and blood pressure-raising sodium. (Read 39873 times). There are Jimmy Johns shops everywhere, and most have a drive through. It's a thumb thinghomemade cheese sauce for dipping at #watertowerpub in Lexington. 601 Shenandoah Village Drive. Everything there is actually pretty fresh and prepared well. EatThis.com is part of the AllRecipes Food Group. Gonzo: I like Potbelly. Eat on Michigan! Blimpie has been around for more than 50 years, with locations across the country. For our ranking of cold subs, we primarily looked at calories, sodium, and fat, with bonus points awarded for protein. Gonzo: I like how loaded it came, and the meats here were really nice. We're as shocked as you are, and frankly, rather disappointed it ranks so poorly against the competition. Adding ham to The Number Four tacks on about 275 milligrams of sodium and 40 calories. Tony Dec 5, 2021 at 6:45 pm. It makes sense because Subway is cheap and consistent you know what you're going to get and you're not going to spend too much. His friend made a tomato pie. The beef is warmed up and then smothered in BBQ sauce. Olivia Tarantino is the Managing Editor of Eat This, Not That!, specializing in nutrition, health, and food product coverage. But for $4, I guess you get what you pay for. This can take a minute, so be prepared. lad May 7, 2019 at 4:36 pm, R.Kelly Apr 2, 2019 at 3:30 pm. } Youre basically just tasting a vinegar sub. The meat here is not great quality, which is a major blow. But since prices vary from state to state when you consider composition, bread and ingredient taste, and overall flavor, there's no beating Potbelly. Like how do they even make that sandwich that fast? "This sub has the least amount of saturated and trans fats of almost all the subs," says L.J. Photos by Chris Gennone, (from the 558-560 Newark Avenue, Jersey City location). There are plenty more unsuspecting foods with more fat than a Big Mac. The leading independent voice for aviation news and insight. JJ I dont really understand. However, the standard Primo size costs $10.99 which is a little high for a chain. Poor customer service, poor quality of food and poor sandwich skills. The last memory I have of eating a Blimpie sandwich was in the Boy Scouts when I was probably 11 or 12 years old. Below is our breakdown of every sub on the Jersey Mike's menu, ranked from best to worst. $2 Off ANY Regular Jersey Mike's Sub. Was told by sorry by employee and that it would only be another 2 seconds. When they make your sandwich, they cut the meat in front of you to show you how fresh it really is. I ordered the same sandwichan Italian subfrom each chain. In this particular article we will give you some of the highlights of Jersey Mikes Blt Sub. Rude customer service manager told me to stop talking. as well as other partner offers and accept our, According to foodservice research company, 's 2017 chain restaurant study, reported on by. So if you are in a hurry, Jimmy John's is by far your best choice. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. scanned through all the nutrition data to rank the best and worst subs for your waistline. The potbelly bread was the heartiest of the breads, and tasted very fresh. So for the same price you can get an eight-inch sandwich at Jimmy John's or something half the size at Jersey Mike's. Not terrible. All Rights Reserved. We had the "Vito", which is their original Italian sub with salami, capicola ham, provolone, onion, lettuce, tomato, and not enough Italian vinaigrette. I've never had a Firehouse Subs location (and I've probably been to 20+) refuse to put exactly what I want on my sub. By the time I finished paying, my sandwich was already ready. We've ranked them from worst to best, and would love to hear if you agree. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. Industry, tourism and local traffic would be gone or severely crippled without it being in functioning condition in BOTH states. Would You Like to Convert It Into Review? Love the sisters at Bommarito's in St. Clair Shores! Here in New Jersey, no one should ever have to rely on any kind of deli sandwich chain. Ive had my fair share of Wawa sandwiches, and theyve all ranged from dull to decent. These might not be the best in the country but they are pretty dang good. More than 2,000 locations open and under development throughout the United States. But this sub was made and wrapped perfectly. They use a lean turkey breast with no additives and flavorful provolone cheese. At both restaurants, my total was roughly six dollars. var xhr = new XMLHttpRequest(); I finally gave Jimmy Johns a fair try today to compare to Jersey Mikes. "Sweet Tea" is brown colored sugar water. The lettuce, tomatoes and onions were fine, and a little on the thicker side. Great bread to meat ratio, the whole bun was perfectly covered. The Best & Worst Menu Items at Jersey Mike's. This was one sandwich that actually surprised us with how decent it was. And now after trying to be cordial, they refuse to help me. Everything on this one kind of melded into one flavor, which was pretty good. Nobody's gonna mention Firehouse! Classic Italian: Bread: 6.7 Fillings: 6.7 Toppings: 6.7 Value: 7.6 Overall: 6.9, QuickCheks classic Italian sub, left, and Primo Hoagies Italian sub. No, not a pizza, but a pie with tomatoes in it. Reading all of these reviews have me worried about trying Firehouse, JJs or Jersey Mikes. So next time you get in the mood for a cold cut, I highly recommend you ditch Jersey Mikes and give Jimmy Johns a try. Per regular sub, prepared Mike's Way: 830 calories, 43 g fat (9 g saturated fat, 1 g trans fat), 2,081 mg sodium, 70 g carbs (4 g fiber, 10 g sugar), 39 g protein. The store, Jersey mikes customer support, etc Emma told me, well the number 9 comes with mayo! At Jimmy Johns, a sandwich with chips and a drink is around $8, so you definitely get more for your money. It was $8.75. Although picking out villains from the heroes may be hard at first glance, we here at Eat This, Not That! I also ruled against including Potbelly because theres only one Garden State location, and Panera and Charleys Philly Steaks just dont really fit the profile. Overall, Primos is just a quality sub with fresh ingredients. Jersey Mikes Is DEFINITELY BETTER AND DEFINITELY FRESHER . Its slightly buttery and light and I appreciate the fact that they rip the breading out for certain sandwiches.